Redskins and Dolphins trade (approved)

Redskins get: Vonnie Holliday

Dolphins get: #43 rookie pick, #46 rookie pick, Kedric Golston

Redskins agree

Dolphins Agree

whhat is golstons rating?

no way this trade will pass, 43, 46 will be low 70's, holliday will be 85/86 and golston, even tho much younger, does not even closely match holliday's productivity.

Holiday is an 87 w/ updates, IMO its unfair, but not by much, Goston is young but is low rated, and a 2 seconds wont make a huge difference, but its not totally off.

can someone show me golstons rating?

catspajamas wrote:

Holiday is an 87 w/ updates, IMO its unfair, but not by much, Goston is young but is low rated, and a 2 seconds wont make a huge difference, but its not totally off.

i know... old 87 for young 80 who will get a lot better and two mid-high 70s.

nerd wrote:

can someone show me golstons rating?

golston is a low 80

ill approve it, anyone have any more objections

it wont be mid-high. it'll be low 70's-high 60's.

nerd wrote:

it wont be mid-high. it'll be low 70's-high 60's.

umm dude what are you talking about. players could fall from the 1st round since those are two high 2nd rounders.... usama young is a 74, and he was like the last pick of the 2nd round.

Usama Young is not a 74 dude. theirs 7 players in the first round that are 80s. Robert Meachem is a 77 and Anthony Gonzales is a 74. Those picks will be 72s tops.

mksadng wrote:

Usama Young is not a 74 dude. theirs 7 players in the first round that are 80s. Robert Meachem is a 77 and Anthony Gonzales is a 74. Those picks will be 72s tops.

you can see it in the madden video...

not to mention that people will fall from the first round, and those are just WRs you listed.

What Madden Video???

something on youtube, but, i know i bash how trades are run on this site, but im in another madden league, and alan faneca got traded for todd herremans and a fifth and sixth, im an admin so i said no, but i got outnumbered, so compared to that site these trades are mint, lol

catspajamas wrote:

something on youtube, but, i know i bash how trades are run on this site, but im in another madden league, and alan faneca got traded for todd herremans and a fifth and sixth, im an admin so i said no, but i got outnumbered, so compared to that site these trades are mint, lol

ya there is a youtube video with all the madden 08 ratings but it is nearly impossible to read...

so is this approved?

i will approve it, but i guess i need another mod to also

anyone??

altho i am iffy, i will reluctantly aprove...

you guys do know that those two picks add up to either the 18th or 17th pick in the draft right? I think that the trade should squeeze by

This trade is fine with me as well...Those 2nd rounders could end up being gems by season's end...we all forget that players go up (or down) in ratings throughout the year...

I will approve this one and lock it...