Patriots/ Browns

Patriots
Nnamdi Asomugha 92/ 27
Sidney Rice 78/22
09 third(browns)


Browns
Green 82 DE/ 29
Manning JR 85 Cb/28
Chad Jackson 77 WR/23
09 first (patriots)

I agree

silvabiltz wrote:

Patriots
Nnamdi Asomugha 92/ 27
Sidney Rice 78/22
09 third(browns)


Browns
Green 82 DE/ 29
Manning JR 85 Cb/28
Chad Jackson 77 WR/23
09 first (patriots)

I agree

I think this is a tad lopsided in favor for the Pats. A shutdown CB for relatively cheap IMO

DC wrote:

silvabiltz wrote:

Patriots
Nnamdi Asomugha 92/ 27
Sidney Rice 78/22
09 third(browns)


Browns
Green 82 DE/ 29
Manning JR 85 Cb/28
Chad Jackson 77 WR/23
09 first (patriots)

I agree

I think this is a tad lopsided in favor for the Pats. A shutdown CB for relatively cheap IMO

I'm going to have to agree. Nnamdi Asomugha is a very young shutdown CB who will only continue to improve. Chad Jackson has done nothing so far, I don't think this is a very even deal..

okay, well since it's that bad of a deal then, toss it into Rejected, because the Patriots aren't interested in getting robbed of more.

HCWesWilliams wrote:

okay, well since it's that bad of a deal then, toss it into Rejected, because the Patriots aren't interested in getting robbed of more.

You robbed? You guys are robbing the Browns, but thats just like the Patriots to cheat people. First video tapes what next

DC wrote:

HCWesWilliams wrote:

okay, well since it's that bad of a deal then, toss it into Rejected, because the Patriots aren't interested in getting robbed of more.

You robbed? You guys are robbing the Browns, but thats just like the Patriots to cheat people. First video tapes what next

I didn't say we were getting robbed in this deal. I'm just saying we're not willing to give up more, so there's no point in trying to renegotiate this deal.

DC wrote:

HCWesWilliams wrote:

okay, well since it's that bad of a deal then, toss it into Rejected, because the Patriots aren't interested in getting robbed of more.

You robbed? You guys are robbing the Browns, but thats just like the Patriots to cheat people. First video tapes what next

wait don't put this into rejection

i wanna put some stuff out

silvabiltz wrote:

wait don't put this into rejection

i wanna put some stuff out

ok

ok we you first look at you deal you think Manning is not in the same league as Nandi but look at stat wise there not far off except AWR

agilty Nandi 90<manning 93
awr nandi 90> manning 74
catch Nandi 74< Manning 78
jump Nadi 92> Manning 90
speed Nandi 91>Manning 90
Stamina Nandi 88< Manning 90


as you see Nandi is only better than manning big time is AWR and everything else is just 50/50 for each player. so than you telling me jarvis green anthor 82 player who has amazing strentgh, tackle

than we add a first round pick which is than a young stud who is around 82 with amazing potetial

than chad jackson VS Sidney rice
http://www.simsportsnet.com/madden/ratings/player-compare.asp

they are all extremly close except injury really, everything else is just close


and age wise chad jackson and manning are only 1 year older than Nandi and Rice.

so what is the problem with this trade besides names ?

...Awareness is huge in madden, it determines how good a player will be thats why rookies have good stats every where else but their only an 80 because their awareness is like 50

silvabiltz wrote:

ok we you first look at you deal you think Manning is not in the same league as Nandi but look at stat wise there not far off except AWR

agilty Nandi 90<manning 93
awr nandi 90> manning 74
catch Nandi 74< Manning 78
jump Nadi 92> Manning 90
speed Nandi 91>Manning 90
Stamina Nandi 88< Manning 90


as you see Nandi is only better than manning big time is AWR and everything else is just 50/50 for each player. so than you telling me jarvis green anthor 82 player who has amazing strentgh, tackle

than we add a first round pick which is than a young stud who is around 82 with amazing potetial

than chad jackson VS Sidney rice
http://www.simsportsnet.com/madden/ratings/player-compare.asp

they are all extremly close except injury really, everything else is just close


and age wise chad jackson and manning are only 1 year older than Nandi and Rice.

so what is the problem with this trade besides names ?

This is poor. You cant compare Ricky Manning Jr to Nandi. No way at all

mksadng wrote:

...Awareness is huge in madden, it determines how good a player will be thats why rookies have good stats every where else but their only an 80 because their awareness is like 50

Awrness can easily be fixed with playing time ,

more a player plays the higher the awrness

would this be better

Patriots
Nnamdi Asomugha 92/ 27
09 third(browns)


Browns
Green 82 DE/ 29
Manning JR 85 Cb/28
09 first (patriots)

silvabiltz wrote:

would this be better

Patriots
Nnamdi Asomugha 92/ 27
09 third(browns)


Browns
Green 82 DE/ 29
Manning JR 85 Cb/28
09 first (patriots)

make the 3rd a later pick, and id vote yes

i don't think i can do that

and look at stats

Nnamdi Asomugha - 33 tackles - 0 sacks - 1 INT
Ricky Manning - 23 tackles - 0 sacks - 4 INT


and manning was my number 2/3 CB last season while Nnamdi should have been there number 1

silvabiltz wrote:

and look at stats

Nnamdi Asomugha - 33 tackles - 0 sacks - 1 INT
Ricky Manning - 23 tackles - 0 sacks - 4 INT


and manning was my number 2/3 CB last season while Nnamdi should have been there number 1

nnamdi went on IR in like week 6

alright 4th rounder next year, fifth rounder this year ?

?

silvabiltz wrote:

would this be better

Patriots
Nnamdi Asomugha 92/ 27
09 third(browns)


Browns
Green 82 DE/ 29
Manning JR 85 Cb/28
09 first (patriots)

I personally think this is good.
Green > 3rd
85 Manning + 1st < 92 Asomugha

Ruskie89 wrote:

silvabiltz wrote:

would this be better

Patriots
Nnamdi Asomugha 92/ 27
09 third(browns)


Browns
Green 82 DE/ 29
Manning JR 85 Cb/28
09 first (patriots)

I personally think this is good.
Green > 3rd
85 Manning + 1st < 92 Asomugha

Finally someone agrees with me

some one delted this

i know this was going to get rejected, that why me and bigz had this trade

Patriots
Nnamdi Asomugha 92/ 27
09 third(browns)


Browns
Green 82 DE/ 29
Manning JR 85 Cb/28
09 first (patriots)


so i'm just going to make a new post and get rid of all this cluter

Sounds to me like the Patriots are getting Shafted.