Titans/Jags(approved)

Titans get: Vince Manuwai and Tardell Sands

Jags get: Albert Haynesworth Ben Troupe and 08 6th

titans0021 wrote:

Titans get: Vince Manuwai and Tardell Sands

Jags get: Albert Haynesworth Ben Troupe and 08 6th

This trade is accepted by the Jaguars GM.

As soon as the Titans accept, I am good with this deal

I accept

titans0021 wrote:

Titans get: Vince Manuwai and Tardell Sands

Jags get: Albert Haynesworth Ben Troupe and 08 6th

I dont see how its fair at all. Its off

DC wrote:

titans0021 wrote:

Titans get: Vince Manuwai and Tardell Sands

Jags get: Albert Haynesworth Ben Troupe and 08 6th

I dont see how its fair at all. Its off

Can you explain how it is so unfair? I don't think its really an acceptable reason to just say that...

If you take out Sands, and make the pick a 5th rounder, its ok IMO

cav_fan2 wrote:

DC wrote:

titans0021 wrote:

Titans get: Vince Manuwai and Tardell Sands

Jags get: Albert Haynesworth Ben Troupe and 08 6th

I dont see how its fair at all. Its off

Can you explain how it is so unfair? I don't think its really an acceptable reason to just say that...

Dude Ben Troupe and Albert for Sands who isnt even close to being rated as Albert and Troupe is a stud at TE. He is mid to high 80's dude. This isnt fair at all

Its true... Haynesworth is an 89 I think and Sands is only an 82, Troupe is a STUD and is in the mid 80s i beleive

DC wrote:

cav_fan2 wrote:

DC wrote:

titans0021 wrote:

Titans get: Vince Manuwai and Tardell Sands

Jags get: Albert Haynesworth Ben Troupe and 08 6th

I dont see how its fair at all. Its off

Can you explain how it is so unfair? I don't think its really an acceptable reason to just say that...

Dude Ben Troupe and Albert for Sands who isnt even close to being rated as Albert and Troupe is a stud at TE. He is mid to high 80's dude. This isnt fair at all

Troupe is 81, Haynesworth is 86 I think...Manuwai is a 92 by himself...

haynesworth is an 89 though

mksadng wrote:

Its true... Haynesworth is an 89 I think and Sands is only an 82, Troupe is a STUD and is in the mid 80s i beleive

92 and 82

for

86, 81 and 6th rounder...

if anything, the Jags are getting hosed...Manuwai is a great lineman...Troupe is by no means a "beast"...he is young and has potential, but nothing close to a beast

cav_fan2 wrote:

mksadng wrote:

Its true... Haynesworth is an 89 I think and Sands is only an 82, Troupe is a STUD and is in the mid 80s i beleive

92 and 82

for

86, 81 and 6th rounder...

if anything, the Jags are getting hosed...Manuwai is a great lineman...Troupe is by no means a "beast"...he is young and has potential, but nothing close to a beast

dont forget that the 92 is an OG...

Touchdown Jesus! wrote:

haynesworth is an 89 though

He's 85 (I thought it was 86) in my game...how can he be so different?

Just so everyone knows, I just checked it on the Wii, which I believe are the same ratings as the PS2, Haynesworth is an 88 and Troupe is an 84, edit accidentally typed 85, whereas Sands is an 82, and Manuwai is an 89

Oh, I forgot we were using the PS2 and not the 360...I guess the ratings are gonna be a little off...

This isnt even my deal, but I just didnt see the big deal with it...no deal is perfect, there is always gonna be someone that thinks one team is getting more...

But whatever, your the Admin...its your call

Manuwai a 92 and Tardell an 82.
Haynesworth 89 and Troupe an 86 as well as only a 6th to even it out a bit.

That's pretty dam fair if you ask me.

I know what you're saying cav, it is kind of sad that the ratings differ between next-gen and old/current-gen systems, but those are what I got off of my wii like 2 seconds ago

cav_fan2 wrote:

no deal is perfect

if you trade 2 players with exactly the same stats age height weight and position it would be

Touchdown Jesus! wrote:

cav_fan2 wrote:

no deal is perfect

if you trade 2 players with exactly the same stats age height weight and position it would be

LOL...good point!

also zsirvone, on the system we're using al is an 88 not 89 and troupe is an 84, sorry I was off there, I just checked it, and manuwai is 89

so then this would be an:

88 DT
84 TE

for

89 OG
82 DT

the titans are losing out definately, but I guess if they dont mind then the trade can still happen.

I don't see anything wrong with this trade personally

Touchdown Jesus! wrote:

so then this would be an:

88 DT
84 TE

for

89 OG
82 DT

the titans are losing out definately, but I guess if they dont mind then the trade can still happen.

Now that looks better

Alright, I'll still accept to the trade then. As long as I get that late pick. Anyone have a link where I can go based off of our ratings?

Touchdown Jesus! wrote:

so then this would be an:

88 DT
84 TE

for

89 OG
82 DT

the titans are losing out definately, but I guess if they dont mind then the trade can still happen.

yeah I'm losing a little bit but I'm picking up a very good young OG, and when I'm basically a run 1st, 2nd, and 3rd team, I'm going to need as good of a OL as I can get