Chargers and Raiders(approved)

Chargers Get:
Jonathan Ogden 96 LT
Lito Sheppard 95 CB
Bryce Fisher 85 LE
Ben Leber 81 LOLB
2008 3rd round pick

Raiders Get:
Marcus McNeil 94 LT
Charles Grant 91 LE
Lemar Marshall 87 LOLB
William James 79 CB
2008 1st round pick

I agree

As i look at this trade it isnt fair.

McNiel= odgen because Odgen is really old and McNiel is just 23.
Sheppard, Fischer= Grant, Marshall
James,3rd= a 79 and a 1st? I think the pick should be lower.

max1 wrote:

As i look at this trade it isnt fair.

McNiel= odgen because Odgen is really old and McNiel is just 23.
Sheppard, Fischer= Grant, Marshall
James,3rd= a 79 and a 1st? I think the pick should be lower.

well this is how I put it together if it helps at all

Ogden 96=McNeil 94
Sheppard 95=Grant 91, 08 1st (80 but rookie)
Marshall 87=Fisher 85, Leber 81
leaving 08 3rd (74 but rookie) for James 79

if its still unbalanced I could add in more but I want to get that first in this

i like max's explan... maybe an FA pick?

well I dont think that lito and fisher=grant and marshall
grants older and 4 ovr worse
marshall is the same age as fisher and only 2 ovr worse
and we all know that a 4% difference from 95 to 91 is a lot different than say a 4% difference from 70 to 74. So Lito and Fisher should be considered>Grant and Marshall

Id throw in a 2nd round FA pick but I already traded it away

Well if it helps at all I'm ok parting with my 1st round and I think the trade is fair...

i dont think tha chargers should have to spend a 1st....

catspajamas wrote:

i dont think tha chargers should have to spend a 1st....

exactly my point

Then we will take the picks out of the trade if TS agrees and that should make it more fair ok?

thats fine with me

Then I'll just wait for TS and he can repost it w/o the draft picks involved.

Brianeal23 wrote:

Chargers Get:
Jonathan Ogden 96 LT
Lito Sheppard 95 CB
Bryce Fisher 85 LE
Ben Leber 81 LOLB
2008 3rd round pick

Raiders Get:
Marcus McNeil 94 LT
Charles Grant 91 LE
Lemar Marshall 87 LOLB
William James 79 CB
2008 1st round pick

approved

processed, chargers had two first rounders though so i gave the raiders the seahawks' first