Redskins and Bengals trade(approved)

Redskins get: Deltha O'Neal, G. Holt

Bengals get: Santonio Holmes, Ade Jimoh

Redskins agree

specify on g.holt

c'mon, a 80 and 61 for a 85 and 66, way unfair IMO

SoxNats07 wrote:

Redskins get: Deltha O'Neal, G. Holt

Bengals get: Santonio Holmes, Ade Jimoh

Redskins agree

I dont agree with this. Seeing as Holmes and younger and more valued than O'neal

DC wrote:

SoxNats07 wrote:

Redskins get: Deltha O'Neal, G. Holt

Bengals get: Santonio Holmes, Ade Jimoh

Redskins agree

I dont agree with this. Seeing as Holmes and younger and more valued than O'neal

What do you mean? I don't mind the trade by the way... Holmes is young and really good, and O'Neal is old cats.. Holt is some 4th string WR.

Its fair IMO. Sox is upgrading at a needed pos. And he has depth at WR. While Cincy is upgrading at WR a needed pos.

yea ok, wtv,

max1 wrote:

Its fair IMO. Sox is upgrading at a needed pos. And he has depth at WR. While Cincy is upgrading at WR a needed pos.

Is he really upgrading more at WR? He is losing out in this deal actually. Holmes may have more value but Oneal is a vet that has good awarness

DC wrote:

max1 wrote:

Its fair IMO. Sox is upgrading at a needed pos. And he has depth at WR. While Cincy is upgrading at WR a needed pos.

Is he really upgrading more at WR? He is losing out in this deal actually. Holmes may have more value but Oneal is a vet that has good awarness

his #2 WR is johnnie lee higgins, a 75.

SoxNats07 wrote:

DC wrote:

max1 wrote:

Its fair IMO. Sox is upgrading at a needed pos. And he has depth at WR. While Cincy is upgrading at WR a needed pos.

Is he really upgrading more at WR? He is losing out in this deal actually. Holmes may have more value but Oneal is a vet that has good awarness

his #2 WR is johnnie lee higgins, a 75.

He will get better as will Holmes but he is losing out on Defense. Defense wins Championships and with or without Holmes his Offense is pretty bad

His D is bad already.

max1 wrote:

His D is bad already.

So why make is worst by trading his best CB?

Its fair. He has a lot of depth at CB and not at WR...his #2 goes up from 75 to 81 and then in turn his slot Reciever goes up from 65 to 75 with JLH moving down...this trade helps his O while hurts his D but his D has 2 good young Corners w.o O'Neal

Not his best CB... He has Carlos Rogers 87 and Johnathan Joseph 85. He has Joseph starting over O'Neal anyway.... I think he is going with the youth movement.

So hes losing his good 3rd Corner to upgrade at WR his biggest need...its a good trade for both sides

RpAaVtEsNS wrote:

So hes losing his good 3rd Corner to upgrade at WR his biggest need...its a good trade for both sides

I know.

https://madden08league.forummotion.com/Teams-c2/AFC-North-c4/Cincinnati-Bengals-f12/Trade-Block-t257.htm

Does that count as him agreeing?

processed